article/comments
article/share
News
Why Did Ottoman Sultan Abdülhamid II Ban a Leo Tolstoy Book?

Why Did Ottoman Sultan Abdülhamid II Ban a Leo Tolstoy Book?

google-g-white cross-white onedio-o-white
Add Onedio as a preferred source on Google plus-blue

Two sets of documents in the Ottoman Archives that mention Leo Tolstoy show the beginning and the end of the same ban. In 1901, Sultan Abdülhamid II barred one of the writer's books from entering the country and had copies collected from bookshops. Five years later, when two newspapers in Beirut quoted Leo Tolstoy, Istanbul sent warning after warning. So why? The documents give the reason in a single sentence. We read the Ottoman Turkish originals and put them in chronological order.

Scroll Down to Continue chevron-right-grey
Advertisement

15 February 1901: Leo Tolstoy's book was banned by order of the sultan.

15 February 1901: Leo Tolstoy's book was banned by order of the sultan.

A circular written that day by the Ministry of the Interior names Leo Tolstoy's book translated into French, 'Où est l'issue?' ('Where Is the Way Out?'). It orders that the book not be allowed into the country and that all copies found in bookshops be collected. According to the document, the decision was made directly by the will of Abdülhamid II.

The order reached every gate, from customs to the police

The circular went to the ministries of Education and Foreign Affairs, to the customs authority overseeing Istanbul, to the Ministry of Post and Telegraph and to the Ministry of Police. It was also sent to all provinces. The document, however, says nothing about what the book is about or why it was considered objectionable.

The same year, Yıldız Palace filed Leo Tolstoy's memorandum to the Tsar.

The same year, Yıldız Palace filed Leo Tolstoy's memorandum to the Tsar.

A record in the palace archive contains the memorandum Leo Tolstoy submitted to Tsar Nicholas II on the state of Russia. Another piece of correspondence from the same period mentions news of 'Tolstoy's banishment.' What was happening to the writer in Russia was being followed in Istanbul as well.

In 1906, two Beirut newspapers quoted Leo Tolstoy and Istanbul sent repeated warnings.

In 1906, two Beirut newspapers quoted Leo Tolstoy and Istanbul sent repeated warnings.

February 1906: El-İkbâl mentions Leo Tolstoy

An issue of the Arabic-language El-İkbâl, published in Beirut, referred to Leo Tolstoy's works in February 1906. Arif Bey, deputy director of the Domestic Press Administration in Istanbul, noticed it and reported it.

The reason for the ban was a single sentence

The Press Administration's letter reads: 'Muharrir-i merkûm nihayet efkâr-ı muzırrasını neşr ü telkine sâ'î olduğundan âsârının gazetelere dercinin kat'iyyen memnû olmasına…' In other words, because the writer strives to spread and instil harmful ideas, publishing his works in newspapers is strictly forbidden. The document does not say which ideas were considered harmful.

1 March 1906: a warning goes to the Governorate of Beirut

The Ministry of the Interior wrote that the ban had already been communicated to Beirut but had not been followed. It asked the governorate to warn officials so that Leo Tolstoy's works would not appear in newspapers, magazines or pamphlets.

A week later, Semerâtü'l-Fünûn quoted Leo Tolstoy

Semerâtü'l-Fünûn, an Arabic newspaper published in Beirut since 1875, printed several passages from Leo Tolstoy's works in its 7 March 1906 issue. The Press Administration repeated the same reasoning and asked that such writing not be permitted again. In the archive catalogue, the newspaper's name is mistakenly listed as 'Servet-i Fünun,' but the document itself says Semerâtü'l-Fünûn.

April 1906: a second warning to Beirut

The margin of the second letter the Ministry of the Interior sent to the Governorate of Beirut refers to the first warning from early March. Less than five weeks after the first letter, a second warning was needed.

Both newspapers had run into censorship before

In 1899, Semerâtü'l-Fünûn was warned to comply with a ban on publishing Quranic verses and hadiths; in 1904 it was shut down indefinitely over an article deemed harmful, before obtaining a new licence. El-İkbâl, meanwhile, was warned in 1902 for breaking the rule that newspapers could only be printed on white paper.

Source: Ottoman Archives, DH.MKT. 2452/29, 2452/77, 1054/23, 2265/83, 899/71, 617/40; DH.TMIK.M.. 99/78; HR.TH.. 252/24; Y..PRK.TKM.. 44/46; Y..PRK.PT.. 21/2; DH.ŞFR. 336/83.

Scroll Down for Comments and Reactions chevron-right-grey
Advertisement

Keşfet ile ziyaret ettiğin tüm kategorileri tek akışta gör!

category/test-white Test
category/gundem-white Gündem
category/magazin-white Magazin
category/video-white Video
category/eglence REACT TO THIS CONTENT WITH EMOJI!
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Scroll Down for Comments chevron-right-grey
Advertisement
WHAT ARE ONEDIO MEMBERS SAYING?
Send Comment