Criticism Arises Over Striking Resemblance Between "Irish Wish" and Classic Rom-Com "27 Dresses"
Netflix's latest romantic comedy film, 'Irish Wish,' has come under scrutiny for its striking similarities to the 2008 classic, '27 Dresses.' As comparisons between the two films surface, critics have raised concerns about the derivative nature of 'Irish Wish' in relation to its predecessor. Let's delve into the details.
Unveiling the Plot: Similarities Between "Irish Wish" and "27 Dresses"
'Irish Wish,' directed by Janeen Damian and written by Kirsten Hansen, follows the story of Maddie, the editor of renowned author Paul Kennedy, as she searches for true love by making a wish on an ancient stone in Ireland. The film's narrative bears a notable resemblance to '27 Dresses,' where protagonist Jane Nichols finds herself in a similar predicament of seeking love while her sister's impending wedding looms large.
Despite the thematic similarities, 'Irish Wish' has quickly ascended Netflix's popularity charts, garnering attention from viewers. However, critical reception has been lukewarm, with the film receiving a meager score of 34 out of 100 on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics have dismissed it as a compilation of romantic comedy clichés, relegating it to the realm of forgettable entertainment.
Exploring the Reception
While '27 Dresses,' directed by Anne Fletcher and written by Aline Brosh McKenna, achieved box office success, it too faced criticism for its reliance on formulaic storytelling. Critics pointed out its predictable plot and clichéd tropes, resulting in a modest score of 40 on Rotten Tomatoes. Similarly, 'Irish Wish' has been deemed as another iteration of the romantic comedy genre's weaknesses, earning comparisons to 'soap opera' due to its superficial narrative.
Send Comment