Controversial Oscar Winners: Are They Actually Masterpieces?
Every year, we eagerly await the Academy's decision on the best films and performances of the year. However, as viewers, we may not always fully agree with these decisions. Recently, we asked viewers about their opinions on Oscar winners or nominations they didn't like, and we've compiled 12 responses highlighting viewer disagreements with the Academy's choices and their comments on the matter. Here are some of the comments where viewers stand against the Academy's selections 👇
12. Shakespeare in Love (1998)
IMDb: 7.1
People believe that Judi Dench's role in the film was minimal, with only eight minutes of screen time. Additionally, many think that Gwyneth Paltrow's performance wasn't deserving of recognition, especially compared to other films like Saving Private Ryan. There's also a perception that Harvey Weinstein influenced the Oscars.
11. Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008)
IMDb: 7.1
Many viewers feel that Penelope Cruz did well in Vicky Cristina Barcelona, but they argue that Amy Adams in Doubt deserved the recognition more that year.
10. The Shape of Water (2017)
IMDb: 7.3
Viewers were disappointed with The Shape of Water, expecting something more akin to The Little Mermaid meets The Phantom of the Opera. There's a general sentiment that the film didn't meet expectations and lacked a clear direction.
9. Promising Young Woman (2020)
IMDb: 7.5
Despite commendable aspects like art direction and cinematography, some believe that Emerald Fennell's win for the screenplay wasn't justified. They acknowledge her direction as impressive but question the script's award-worthiness.
8. Crash (2004)
IMDb: 7.7
Opinions vary regarding Crash's Best Picture win. Many argue that it wasn't the standout film of the year, with Brokeback Mountain being favored by some as a more deserving winner.
7. Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022)
IMDb: 7.8
Some viewers feel that Stephanie Hsu's performance in Everything Everywhere All at Once was overlooked, despite her portrayal being praiseworthy.
6. Dallas Buyers Club (2013)
IMDb: 7.9
There's surprise expressed at Jared Leto's performance in Dallas Buyers Club, with some feeling it was unsettling and perhaps not the right casting choice for a transgender character.
5. La La Land (2016)
IMDb: 8
Many viewers were let down by La La Land, expecting a classic musical but finding it lacking in depth and direction. Some perceive it as a film that didn't fully embrace either being a musical or a drama.
4. Green Book (2018)
IMDb: 8.2
While acknowledging Green Book's interesting story and performances, some question why it was told from a white perspective, especially given the racial themes.
3. Oppenheimer (2023)
IMDb: 8.4
Oppenheimer has received mixed reviews, with some viewers feeling it didn't live up to expectations and overshadowed other great films of the time.
2. Forrest Gump (1994)
IMDb: 8.8
Many believe that Forrest Gump was overrated and not the most deserving film of its year, with other contenders like Pulp Fiction and The Shawshank Redemption seen as more worthy.
1. The Dark Knight (2008)
IMDb: 9
Despite its popularity, there are differing opinions about Heath Ledger's performance in The Dark Knight. Some feel it was overhyped, especially considering his untimely death, while others believe it didn't stand out as much as portrayed.
Send Comment